At JJ Gandy’s Pies, baking incredible pies isn’t just what we do—it’s what we’ve been known for in Palm Harbor for over 40 years. Every pie is made fresh with quality ingredients, time-tested recipes, and the same commitment to flavor that built our reputation.
From our world-famous Key Lime creations to rich cream pies and classic fruit favorites, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
$28.95
Our signature category—and the reason so many customers keep coming back.
Our signature category—and the reason so many customers keep coming back.
Our famous original. Smooth, tangy, and perfectly balanced with sweetness.
A delicious twist featuring a rich Oreo crust paired with our signature key lime filling.
A tropical blend of creamy key lime and sweet coconut flavor.
A colorful, eye-catching pie with layers of tropical-inspired flavor.
A refreshing citrus favorite with a smooth, creamy finish.
A classic favorite with creamy filling and real banana flavor.
Light, smooth, and full of coconut flavor.
Deep, rich chocolate in every bite.
A creamy, nutty favorite that’s perfectly balanced and satisfying.
A layered chocolate and cream delight with bold flavor.
Bright, smooth, and refreshingly citrusy.
Simple, smooth, and delicious on its own.
A creamy cheesecake loaded with chocolate chips.
A rich combination of cheesecake and brownie flavor.
Strawberry, Cherry, Blueberry, Red Raspberry
A traditional favorite with a perfectly baked crust.
Topped with a crumbly, buttery streusel.
Sweet and slightly tart with bold fruit flavor.
Bright and fresh with a natural sweetness.
Rich, deep berry flavor in every slice.
A tangy and vibrant fruit favorite.
Sweet, nutty, and perfectly baked.
A unique twist combining rich, sweet flavors into one unforgettable pie.
Whether you’re picking up a pie for a special occasion or just treating yourself, every JJ Gandy’s pie is made fresh and crafted with care.
From classic favorites to signature creations, JJ Gandy’s Pies delivers the flavor that’s kept customers coming back for decades.
