Shop

Established Local Favorite

Pre-order JJ Gandy’s Pies, Cookies, and Sweet Treats

JJ Gandy’s is open Tuesday – Saturday, 9 am – 5 pm. We suggest preordering your goodies in advance if you need them for someone special.

Jj Gandys Famous Key Lime Pie
Large Key Lime Pie
Our award-winning signature recipe. Rich, tart, and creamy filling made with real key lime juice on a scratch-baked buttery graham cracker crust.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
key lime cuties
Key Lime Cuties
Delightful bite-sized key lime tarts. Perfect for parties, gatherings, or a quick sweet-and-sour afternoon snack.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
key lime cutie
12 Key Lime Cookies
A full dozen of our melt-in-your-mouth key lime cookies, glazed to sweet perfection with a citrus drizzle.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
orange cookies
12 Orange Cookies
Twelve wonderfully fragrant, soft-baked cookies bursting with fresh Florida orange zest and iced glaze.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
12 Mixed Orange & Key Lime
The perfect citrus assortment! Get 6 of our signature Key Lime cookies and 6 Sweet Orange cookies in one box.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
Pops Pie
An extra deep, rich rendition of our classic Key Lime Pie. Built according to “Pops” original heavy-crumble crust specifications.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
keylimewich
Key Limewich
Our proprietary dessert sandwich. Creamy, cooling key lime cream filling pressed between two soft, sweet cookies.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
orange chocolate dreamwich
Orange Chocolate Dreamwich
Decadent chocolate fudge cookies hugging a refreshing orange cream filling. A magical citrus-cocoa harmony.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
chocolate dipped key lime pie
Key lime Slice Dipped in Chocolate
A frozen wedge of our famous Key Lime pie on a stick, hand-dipped into a rich chocolate shell. Creamy, tart, and crunchy!
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order

Available Beginning Wednesday

Large Apple Pie
Fresh sliced crisp apples seasoned with aromatic warm cinnamon and brown sugar, wrapped in a super flaky golden double crust.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
cherry pie
Large Cherry Pie
Juicy, tart wild cherries in an elegant custom pastry crust, baked to bubbling perfection. A classic americana dessert.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
Blueberry
Large Blueberry Pie
Plump, antioxidant-rich wild blueberries baked to sweet, bubbling consistency under a handmade weave lattice crust.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
Large Coconut Cream Pie
Smooth, rich vanilla-coconut custard piled high with dairy whipped cream and sprinkled with fresh toasted coconut flakes.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order
Banana Cream Pie 0
Large Banana Cream Pie
Thick layers of fresh banana slices submerged in rich pastry cream, nestled in our graham crust and loaded with whipped cream.
PRICING
Stripe Secure Checkout
Order

Powered by
►
Necessary cookies enable essential site features like secure log-ins and consent preference adjustments. They do not store personal data.
None
►
Functional cookies support features like content sharing on social media, collecting feedback, and enabling third-party tools.
None
►
Analytical cookies track visitor interactions, providing insights on metrics like visitor count, bounce rate, and traffic sources.
None
►
Advertisement cookies deliver personalized ads based on your previous visits and analyze the effectiveness of ad campaigns.
None
Powered by